Risk assessment for ingestion of off-season longan stimulated by potassium chlorate

Theerayut Baubhom, Kannikar Chatsantiprapa

Abstract


Off-season longans in Thailand were stimulated by potassium chlorate (KClO3). KClO3 is hazardous chemical and prohibited in food since it might cause harm to human health. This research aimed to observe for chemical effects on longan trees, and analyze the chemical residues in longan fruits including ClO3-, Cl-, K+ and N+, and perform risk assessment for health effects from ingestion. Forty-two longan trees (Dimocarpus longan Lour.) were separated into 8 study groups (n=5) and a control group (n=2). Four dosages of KClO3 were used according to trees’ bush size, from 25 g/m to 127 g/m. Each dose was for 2 groups, 1 group stimulation via roots and 1 group stimulation via leaves. After application, longan trees were observed for effects on growth, and fruits were collected to analyze for chemical residues at 150, 180 and 210 days. UV-Spectrophotometer was used for ClO3- and Cl- analyses, and Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer for K+ and Na+ analyses. Results showed that after KClO3 application all longan trees had leaves dropped with burned appearance, with lower dose lesser effects and higher dose more effects. Group control grew fruits the earliest and produced bigger fruits than all treated groups at each observation until at fruits-picking time to find that the fruits of group control were the smallest of all. From the growth of longan fruits, we concluded that 43 g/m of KClO3 should have been the maximum stimulation dose to use for increasing the growth yields for farmer’s benefits, higher dose than this would reduce the benefits, and 25g/m was sufficient for off-season stimulation without significant reduction of yields. Higher KClO3 doses were found to result in higher ClO3-, Cl-, K+, Na+ residues in the peel, but accumulation of related chemical residues in the flesh were inconclusive. Application of KClO3 via roots gave higher accumulation of ClO3- and Cl- residues in the flesh comparing to application via leaves for the same doses. Nevertheless, the study found that stimulation of KClO3 via roots was a better choice than stimulation via leaves for the same doses when considering for better flesh weights and less adverse effects on plants. The risk assessment for chemical residues found that ingestion of 1,000 g of longan flesh per day was safe since they were all HQ << 1.00, or MOS >> 1.00 for all chemical residues. Therefore, there was no worry for toxicities to concern for general consumers from ingestion of off-season longan flesh within our study settings except for those who had particular underlying health conditions.

Full Text:

96-104;PDF

References


Depart of Agricultural. (n.d.). Backtrack story of potassium chlorate. Available from http://www.doa. go.th/pibai/pibai/n17/v_9-oct/rai.html

Bernardo EO, Matos RI, Dawood T, Whiteway SL. (2015). Maternal Cautopyreiophagia as a Rare Cause of Neonatal Hemolysis: A Case Report; 135(3):8–13.

Steffen C, Wetzel E. (1993). Chlorate poisoning: mechanism of toxicity. Toxicology 30(2):217-231.

Couri D, Abdel-Rahman MS, Bull RJ. Toxicological effects of chlorine dioxide, chlorite and chlorate. (1982). Environ Health Prespect 46: 13-17.

Thurlow JS, Little DJ, Baker TP, Yuan CM. (2013). Possible potassium chlorate nephrotoxicity associated with chronic matchstick ingestion. Clin Kidney J; 6(3):316–8.

Mutlu H, Silit E, Pekkafali Z, Basekim CC, Kizilkaya E, Ay H, et al. (2003). Case Report Cranial MR Imaging Findings of Potassium Chlorate Intoxication;(August):1396–8.

Potassium chlorate. (n.d.). Potassium and advantages (Online). Available from www.siamchemi.com

Smith D. (2005). Determination of a sodium chlorate dose that results in safe concentrations of tissue residues in beef cattle. Project summary. US Department of Gariculture, Agriculture Research Service.

Surapol Thongtaing. (2009). Report of promotion process for out-of-season longan production in Chomtong District, Chaing Mai. Office of Agricultural Research and Development Region 1, Department of Agriculture, Chaing Mai, Thailand.

Rujira Netphab. (2010). Effects of Chlorate Compounds on soil Properties in Longan Orchard. A thesis of master of sciences (Integrated Science-Mathematic), Graduated school, Chiang Mai University, Thailand.

Chiswell B and Keller-Lehmann B. (1993). Spectrophotometric Method for the determination of Chlorite and Chlorate. Analyst. (November) 118, 1457-1459.

Carmen Dews. (2015). Determination of K, Na, and Zn in Albumin Using Flame AAS. Agilent Technologies. USA

Faculty of Medical Technology, Mahidol University. (n.d.). Chloride balance; Potassium; Sodium balance. Available from http://www. mt.mahidol.ac.th/elearning/bodyfluid%20and%20electrolyte/chloride.htm;

http://www.mt.mahidol.ac.th/elearning/bodyfluid%20and%20electrolyte/potassium.htm;

http://www.mt.mahidol.ac.th/elearning/bodyfluid%20and%20electrolyte/sodium.htm

Mari Asami, Nobue Yoshida, Koji Kosaka, Koichi Ohno, Yoshihiko Matsui. (2013). Contribution of tap water to chlorate and perchlorate intake: A market basket study, Science of the Total Environment 463–464 (2013) 199–208

ChemSafetyPro. (n.d.). How to Calculate Hazard Quotient (HQ) and Risk Quotient (RQ). Retrieved October 6, 2018, from https://www.chemsafetypro.com/Topics/CRA/How_to_Calculate_Hazard_Quotients_(HQ)_and_Risk_Quotients_(RQ).html

Soradech Jantiang. (2013). Chlorate residues in soil and agriculture economically investment from potassium chlorate used in longan trees plant. A thesis of master of sciences (Geosocial Based Sustainable Development), Maejo University, Chiang Mai, Thailand

Srikanjana Klayraung, Tapana Cheunbarn, Piyanuch Niamsup, Narin Wongkattiya. (2012). Chlorate digestion by chlorate reducing bacteria separated from soil and wastewater sludge. Maejo University, Chiang Mai, Thailand.

Plant physiology. (n.d). Hormone. Available from http://web.agri.cmu.ac.th/hort/course/359311/ PPHY10_hormone.htm#aba

Huang XM, Lu JM, Wang HC, Zhang CL, Xie L, Yang RT, Li JG, Huang HB. (2006). Nitrate reduces the detrimental effect of potassium chlorate on longan (Dimocarpus longan Lour.) trees. Sci Hortic, 108:151-156.

Lu J, Yang R, Wang H, and Huang X. (2017). Stress effects of chlorate on longan (Dimocarpus longan Lour.) trees: Changes in nitrogen and carbon nutrition. Horticultural Plant Journal 3(6):237-246.

Lin CC, Chung YC, Hsu CP. (2012). Potential roles of longan flower and seed extracts for anticancer. World J Exp Med 2(4):078-85.

Potchanasin P, Sringarm K, Naphrom D, Bangerth KF.(2009). Floral induction in longan (Dimocarpus longan, Lour.) trees. IV.The essentiality of mature leaves for potassium chlorate induced floral induction and associated hormonal changes. Sci Hortic (Amsterdam). 122(2) :312–7.

WHO. (2009). A Risk-Based Decision Tree Approach for the Safety Evaluation of Residues of Veterinary Drugs. Retrieved October 6, 2018, from

http://www.who.int/foodsafety/chem/jecfa/decision_tree_mar_2009_final_for_web.pdf


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.